Two women caught on tape abusing Seals at a California beach brings national spotlight on animal abuse
he images of seals being harassed on a California beach are perplexing and disturbing.
In the middle of the
night, two women sit on harbor seals, kick them or pull their flippers,
all the while snapping flash pictures. The animals eventually flee into
the water.
A newly installed video
camera captures that attack and others on the seals, who have been using
the beach at Children's Pool in La Jolla for decades.
Sara Wan of the Western
Alliance for Nature said her organization installed the camera after
years of people who are opposed to the seals' presence on the beach
being cruel to the animals, trying to scare them off the sand.
A woman is seen harassing a seal in California.
"One of the things we
found with the camera is it shows what we knew was going on before," she
says. "Now people are seeing what is going on and saying, 'You're
right, that's wrong.'"
San Diego Mayor Bob
Filner placed a sunset to sunrise curfew on the beach, saying people can
disagree about how a beach should be used, but they cannot abuse
animals, CNN affilate KGTV reported. The restrictions end May 15 after pupping season is over.
The beach was a popular
spot for parents to take their children for a safe place to swim, but
harbor seals took over the beach in the early 1990s, KGTV said.
Beach-access advocates want the area returned to its original use, the
station reported.
Because most cases of
animal abuse or neglect are never reported, it is difficult to say
whether the number of incidents are increasing.
But with enhanced technology and social media, some of the most egregious cases have recently caught the attention of the media.
There were cases where people apparently were ignorant of the law, such as the woman in Florida who rode a manatee,
and other more serious ones where people showed wanton disregard for
wildlife, as in the case of two sea birds found struggling to breathe
after someone forced beer cans over their heads.
In December, at least 10 dead dolphins washed up on beaches in the Gulf Coast. Some were shot, while others were stabbed.
It makes you wonder, what is wrong with people?
"I really don't
understand how someone can be deliberately cruel to an animal like that.
It's really baffling," says Sharon Young, marine issues field director
with the Humane Society of the United States. "They know it's illegal,
they know it's wrong."
Studies have shown that people who have little or no empathy for animals often have none for other humans, activists say.
Animal cruelty is a
crime that mostly goes unreported. A 1997 report from the Massachusetts
Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals says that only 40% of
people who witness abuse ever report it.
The same study found
people who committed violent crimes against animals were five times more
likely to commit violent crimes against humans than were other people
who lived in the same neighborhoods.
According to the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals, there are three reasons people abuse animals.
Most people, the ASPCA
says on its website devoted to children, "don't think about or realize
what they are doing." Take, for instance, the pet owner who doesn't
understand how cruel it is to tie a pet up all day on a chain that is
too short.
Another type of abuser
is the person who is bowing to peer pressure. In those cases, the
person, usually someone young, doesn't hurt or harass animals but a few
times. Eventually, they learn to feel for the animal, the organization
says.
The third category is
people who enjoy hurting animals. These people are often looking to
demonstrate their power, the ASPCA says.
Sometimes, people feel they are at odds with the wildlife, Young says.
It's a clash, where a growing human population wants the same space as the animal population, Wan says. The pressure is growing.
"And more and more we are taking it out on wildlife," she says.
Both Wan and Young agree
that there isn't a problem with the legal penalties for animal cruelty,
but with catching and convicting the bad guys.
"We don't need stronger
laws, but clearly there is a need for stronger enforcement," Young says.
"We need to make proverbial examples of some people."
Her organization works
with groups to educate the public. In the case of the seals, the cruelty
has "accelerated so rapidly" that activists are scrambling to do
something, she said. They hope to create a video that draws attention to
the problem.
For now, she and Wan hope the beach closure will help give the seals a respite from the types of incidents caught on camera.